When it comes to live performances this year, I’ve taken in more than my fair share. I’m talking big Broadway musicals (Gypsy, Smash, Operation Mincemeat), buzzy concerts featuring major divas (Kylie, Beyoncé) and even sports soap operas (aka a live-taping of WWE’s Raw for Netflix). But this week, I saw one event at Madison Square Garden in New York City that topped them all: Lady Gaga’s Mayhem Ball concert.

Now, I don’t want you to think I’m biased. I’m not one of Gaga’s Little Monsters who is so obsessed with her that I’d give her concert a rave review no matter what (something I suspect a few Swifties did last year, but that’s neither here nor there). I’m a gay man, so naturally I like Lady Gaga. It’s hard not to after hearing her songs played at bars, parties, clubs and on the radio since 2008. The woman is freaking talented. But my expectations going into my first time seeing her live? She’d be really good, great even. And yet, my expectations were surpassed on every single level. I enjoyed her Mayhem Ball so much that I’m calling it the best live theatrical event of 2025.

Here, my honest review of Gaga’s Mayhem Ball.