Taco Bell had a lasting impact on my aughts-era adolescence. Bean burritos with my dad, scarfed down after swim practice. A loitering sesh with friends, Crunchwraps in tow. A dozen tacos, split between me and my first love. Needless to say, when the fast food chain announced the release of its Decades Y2K Menu, I was stoked.

The menu brought back five discontinued items from the 2000s that fans have been missing for years. I’m talking the famed Chili Cheese burrito, my beloved Double Decker Taco and a dessert that surely has the Cinnabon Delights shaking in its cinnamon sugar-coated boots. To see if the lineup is as tasty as I remember, I visited the nearest store to try them all. Read on for my original photos, honest reviews and overall ranking.

(Note: Pricing and availability may vary by location. Prices are rounded to the nearest half-dollar.)

6 Taco Bell Breakfast Menu Items, Ranked and Reviewed by a Food Editor