As PureWow’s food editor, I’m typically in the know about what delicious new products are at Trader Joe’s. In fact, I review new foods and drinks every month to find out which are worth the hype. Now that it’s spooky season at the cult-favorite grocery chain, I figured it was time to try as many autumnal items as I could get my hands on and report back to our readers on the best and worst picks of the season. (I know, I know, you can thank me later.)

Here, you’ll find my honest reviews, original photos and overall ranking of ten Trader Joe’s fall products, ranging from All Butter Apple Shortbread Cookies to Butternut Squash Mac & Cheese. And in case you’re worried about splurging a little too much, know that this entire list cost me $38 flat in Philadelphia, which wasn’t as much as I expected.

The 8 Best Trader Joe’s Frozen Foods, According to Our Editors